Month: May 2012

Mediation: Fourth District, Division 1, Affirms Trial Court’s Determination Defendant Agreed to “Binding Mediation”

Court of Appeal Concludes Binding Mediation Need Not Be An Oxymoron, Distinguishing Lindsay v. Lewandowski      The trial court enforced a settlement agreement, under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. section 664.6, resulting in a binding mediation award in favor of plaintiffs.  Defendant appealed, contending that it never agreed to resolve the dispute through “binding mediation”, that […]

News: California Assembly Rejects Expanding Role of Mediators Before Municipalities Can File For Bankruptcy–At Least For Now

May 30, 2012 · News

AB 1692 Would Expand AB 506      CBS News reports that the state Assembly has rejected legislation (AB 1692) seeking to expand the mediation process for California cities about to declare bankruptcy.      At the end of last year, AB 506, drafted by Assemblyman Bob Wieckowski (D – Fremont), created a mediation requirement for municipalities […]

Arbitration/Fees: Plaintiff’s Request for Fees for Defeating a Petition to Compel Arbitration in Pending Lawsuit Is Unsuccessful, Because Defendant Prevailed In the Whole Lawsuit

  Under Civil Code Section 1717, There May Be Only One Prevailing Party Entitled to Recover Attorney’s Fees on Given Contract In Given Lawsuit      The key to our next case, involving arbitration and attorney’s fees, turns on a nice point that may at first seem a technicality but is actually material and dispositive here. […]

Mediation/Confidentiality/Family Law: Conduct of Parties During Settlement Negotiations Can Support Sanction in Family Law Context

  Whether the Mediation Confidentiality Was Violated Is Not Crystal Clear From the Opinion      We are always pleased when a case has something to say about mediation – there are far fewer written opinions about mediation than about arbitration.       Aaronson petitioned to nullify her marriage with Oslica, on the ground of purported fraud […]

Arbitration/Fees/Waiver/Severability/Standard of Review : In Elder Abuse Case, Court of Appeal Affirms Severance From Arbitration Clause of Waiver of Plaintiff’s Statutory Right to Recover Attorney’s Fees

  Fifth District Explains That By Submitting A Dispute to An Arbitral Forum, A Party Does Not Necessarily Forgo Substantive Statutory Rights      Plaintiff Ruth Chappell (replaced by her trustee Bickel after she died) sued an assisted living facility, Sunrise Assisted Living, for Elder Abuse. Chappell’s written agreement with Sunrise included an arbitration clause specifying […]

Arbitration/Fees/Waiver: Cinel Redux – Not Paying Arbitrator’s Fees Leads to Waiver of Right to Arbitrate

  Once Again, Second District, Division 1 Gets to Explore Legal Consequences of Not Paying All the Arbitrator’s Fees      The parties in Cinel v. Barna, Case No. B232380 (2nd Dist. Div. 1 May 18, 2012) (Johnson, J.) (unpublished) have undoubtedly expended lots of attorney’s fees by now, exploring the legal consequences of not paying […]

Arbitration/Nonsignatories/Scope: Plaintiff’s Mere Allegation of Agency Relationships Is Not Necessarily Enough to Enable Nonsignatory to Take Advantage of Arbitration Provision

  Court of Appeal Delves Further Into Whether Alleged Agency Relationship Relates to Activities Governed By The Arbitration Clause      The underlying dispute among different YMCA organizations, concerned the right to use camp grounds in the Sierra. Plaintiff Central Valley Young Man’s Christian Association, Inc. ran into financial difficulties, as a result of which the […]

In the News: Curtain About to Open On Next Act in Challenge to Arbitrator’s Award of Fees in $70M TV Writers’ Age Discrimination Settlement

May 14, 2012 · News

  Public Spectacle? Dark Comedy? Courtroom Drama? White Noise? Stay Tuned. Above: Aged TV Writer Sits and Ponders the Meaning of It All. Creator: American Red Cross. Albania. 1923. Library of Congress.      In the May 14, 2012 online edition of The National Law Journal, Zoe Tillman writes about the fight over lawyer’s fees following […]

Arbitration/Nonsignatories/Enforcement: Second District, Division 7 Affirms Decision That Plaintiff Was Not Bound By Arbitration Provision In “Close Case”

  Outcome Depended On Capacity In Which Signatory Signed      The trial court determined that Plaintiff Allen Othman was not a party to a contract containing an arbitration provision in an agreement, and therefore was not bound to arbitrate his claims against Zions First National Bank. Mr. Othman had tried to purchase a property through […]