Category: Mediation: Family Law

Confidentiality: Unlike Mediation, Collaborative Law Settlements Do Not Have Statutory Confidentiality Protection

The Lesson Here Is The Importance of Carefully Drafting Collaborative Law Agreements.         How's this for a setup:  "Ling and Paul Mueller married in 2009 and separated in 2017. During their marriage, they cultivated cannabis and buried the proceeds on their property." What could possibly go wrong? Plenty.         The Muellers engaged in a collaborative […]

Mediation/Family Law:Pro Per Father Was Given Fair Opportunity To Oppose Mother’s Request For A Move-Away Order, Despite Feeling Ambushed By Mediator’s Decision To Discuss The Issue

July 20, 2017 · Mediation: Family Law

Under The Circumstances, The Mediator's Decision To Discuss The Mother's Move-Away Request Was "Understandable".         In family law, disputes are often resolved through mediation.  In Alkebulan v. Dunham, D069434 (4/1  7/20/17) (Benke, O'Rourke, Dato) (unpublished), father, who was unrepresented by counsel, felt blind-sided when mother raised the issue of a move-away order with their year-old […]

Mediation, Confidentiality, Family Law: Lacking Mediation Privilege, Unmediated Spousal Settlement Is Set Aside Because Presumption Of Undue Influence Applied

Here’s A Good Example Of Why It Is Harder To Set Aside A Mediated Spousal Settlement Than An Unmediated, Negotiated Settlement.      In Marriage of Cooke, B257791 (2/7 10/17/16) (Segal, J.) (unpublished), the wife moved for entry of a stipulation for judgment that she and her husband signed.  The opinion rather vividly describes the the […]

Mediator: Court of Appeal Reverses $313,206 Jury Award In Favor Of Whistleblowing Mediator

Mediator Gallup Walloped For Failure To Exhaust Administrative Remedies.      Family services mediator Emily Gallup complained to her supervisor and other court management about “insufficient time for mediation appointments, inadequate review of records and gathering of facts, failure to consider criminal histories, failure to advocate for the best interests of the children, failure to offer […]

Mediation/Confidentiality/Family Law/Settlement Agreement: Affirming Trial Court, Second District, Division 1 Agrees Stipulated Judgment Reached Through Mediation Is Enforceable, Despite Failure To File It In Dissolution Proceedings, And Dismissal Of Mari

Stipulated Judgment May Not Have Contained Magic Words, But It Was Sufficient To Express Parties’ Intent To Waive Confidentiality And Allow Enforcement      Daly v. Oyster, B249255 (2/1 July 29, 2014) (Chaney, Johnson, Wiley) (published) deals with that nettlesome situation that sometimes arises after mediation when papers are not filed with the court, the case […]

Mediation/Confidentiality/Family Law: Conduct of Parties During Settlement Negotiations Can Support Sanction in Family Law Context

  Whether the Mediation Confidentiality Was Violated Is Not Crystal Clear From the Opinion      We are always pleased when a case has something to say about mediation – there are far fewer written opinions about mediation than about arbitration.       Aaronson petitioned to nullify her marriage with Oslica, on the ground of purported fraud […]