Author: calmediation

Arbitration, FAA, Unconsionability: First Distriction, Div. 2 Holds FAA Does Not Apply To Transportation Workers And Agreement Is Unconsionable

Court Distinguishes Baltazar.         Plaintiff Sabid Ali sued Daylight Transport, LLC, claiming he had been misclassified as an independent contractor, and alleging various California labor violations. Daylight move to compel arbitration, failed, and appealed. Sabid Ali v. Daylight Transport, LLC, No. A157104 (1/2  12/31/20) (Kline, Richman, Miller) (partial pub.).         In the trial court, Daylight […]

Arbitration, Choice Of Law, Nonsignatories: Foreign Nonsignatory To Partnership Deed Could Not Invoke Equitable Estoppel To Compel Arbitration

The Partnership Deed With The Arbitration Clause Was Entered Into In India, But The Court Applied US Federal Substantive Law To The Equitable Estoppel Issue. Incense for sale in Bangalore. Author: Meanest Indian. Creative Commons License.         Appellant/Defendant Shrinivas Sugandhalaya LLP (SS Mumbai), in a lawsuit with Appellees/Plaintiffs (SS Bangalore), sought to enforce an arbitration […]

Happy New Year 2021 !

January 1, 2021 · Miscellaneous

Library of Congress. December 30, 1908. Albert Levering, artist.         The Puck magazine illustration shows Father Time departing, and taking Thomas C. Platt with him. Platt was a two-term member of Congress and a three-term Senator from New York. According to Wikipedia: "Upon his death, the New York Times stated that 'no man ever exercised less influence […]

Arbitration: Ninth Circuit Rules That Plaintiff’s Voluntary Dismissal With Prejudice, After Defense Motion To Compel Arbitration Is Granted, Does Not Create Appellate Jurisdiction

A SCOTUS Case Effectively Overruled An Earlier Ninth Circuit Opinion.         In Damian Langere v. Verizon Wireless Services, No. 19-55747 (9th Cir.  12/29/20) (Bumatay, Parker, Watford), the court holds, "the voluntary dismissal of claims following an order compelling arbitration does not create appellate jurisdiction."          The rule had been otherwise in the Ninth Circuit in  […]

Arbitration, Qui Tam: Second District, Div. 6 Holds Qui Tam Action Is Not Subject To Arbitration

The Qui Tam Action Is Brought On Behalf Of The State Which Is Not A Party To The Arbitration Agreement.         State of California ex rel. Aetna Health of California, Inc. et al., v. Pain Management Specialist Medical Group et al., B299025 (2/6  12/21/20) (Gilbert, Perren, Tangeman) involves a qui tam action brought under the […]

Arbitration, Disclosures: Arbitrator’s Nondisclosure Of Involvement With LGBTQ Organization Not A Basis For Tossing Arbitration Award

The Arbitrator's Relationship With  GLAAD Was Irrelevant To The Dispute.         The arbitration award was confirmed and affirmed on appeal in Malek Media Group LLC v. AXQG Corp.,  B299743  (12/16/20 )) (Dhanidina, Lavin, Egerton), a case in which the disgruntled appealing party sought to disqualify the arbitrator for failure to disclose his connection with […]

Arbitration, Delegation, Agents: Two Cases In Medical Settings Show California Courts Scrutinize Arbitration Agreements Entered Into For The Sick And The Aged

        California courts continue to scrutinize cases in which hospitals and nursing homes seek to enforce arbitration provisions. The medical settings often involve patients who are old, quite sick (or both), hurried admission processes, and urgency. These cases remind me of a story my law school torts professor told, about taking his daughter, who had […]

Reviews: Sweet Taste Of Liberty: A True Story Of Slavery And Restitution In America

December 5, 2020 · Reviews

Your Blogger Has Reviewed Sweet Taste of Liberty, And Includes A Link To The Review Below.         Rice University historian W. Caleb McDaniel won the Pulitzer Prize in history for this remarkable story about Henrietta Wood, an enslaved person in Kentucky, who was freed in Ohio, kidnapped by a slave broker, re-enslaved, sold in Kentucky, […]