Court Of Appeal Reverses Order Denying Motion To Compel Arbitration Of Class Claim. In an employment dispute, the trial court denied plaintiff' Garner's ability to pursue class action claims in arbitration, relying on "language in the arbitration agreement stating that Garner waived his right to participate in class action lawsuits." Chris Garner v. […]
Plaintiff's Request For Costs Was Made In Court After Plaintiff Beat Her Section 998 Offer During Arbitration. Plaintiff/Appellant Helene Storm prevailed in arbitration over an uninsured motorist claim against an insurance company. Afterwards, she petitioned the trial court to confirm the award in her favor, and to award arbitration and post-arbitration costs […]
The Parties Failed To Initial The Jury Waiver, But They Did Sign A "Certification." "What if neither party to an arbitration agreement places initials next to a jury waiver contained in the agreement, even though the drafter included lines for their initials?" That's the question presented in Martinez v. BaronHR, Inc., et al, B296858 […]
"Nuts and Bolts of Videoconference Dispute Resolution in the Time of Covid-19." With remarkable speed, mediators, arbitrators, judges, and attorneys have learned to use videoconferencing as a work tool. Back in March, after we began "sheltering in place" in California, I drafted an article on the "Nuts and Bolts of Videoconference Dispute Resolution in […]
The Briefing Focused On A "Blow-Up" Provision, But The Court Focused On An Unenforceable Waiver Of PAGA Claims And Lack Of Severability. "Six-year-old Gregorio Drozco III does what a lot of people do in a Seattle, Washington, alley when he blows a bubble, preparatory to wadding up his gum and sticking it to […]
This Case Is Must Reading For Determining Whether An Arbitrator's Ruling Is An Award. "As this case highlights, whether an arbitrator's ruling constitutes an 'award' is a significant event." Lonky v. Patel, B295314 consolidated with B297632 (2/2 7/2/20) (Hoffstadt, Lui, Chavez). Indeed. The arbitrator can continue to issue interim rulings before there […]
July 4th Fireworks In Washington, D.C. July 4, 2008. Carol M. Highsmith, photographer. Library of Congress. "A republic, if you can keep it." – Benjamin Franklin.
The US Supreme Court Was In Agreement About This One. The Supreme Court has held unanimously, with Justice Sotomayor concurring, that the "New York Convention does not conflict with the enforcement of arbitration agreements by nonsignatories under domestic-law equitable estoppel doctrines." GE Energy Power Conversion France SAS v. Outokumpu Stainless USA, […]
And Because The Malicious Prosecution Plaintiff Cannot Win, An Anti-SLAPP Motion By Defendant Succeeds. The holding of Dorit v. Noe, A157433 (1/3 5/26/20) (Brown, Pollak, Tucher) is that a malicious prosecution cause of action cannot be based on a mandatory fee arbitration act (MFAA) arbitration. Along the way to its conclusion, the […]
A party that wishes to pursue arbitration must take “ ‘active and decided steps to secure that right’ . . ." Why? Because an arbitration agreement is not self-executing. In Fleming Distribution Company v. Alfons Younan, A157038 (3/1 5/15/20) (Petrou, Fujisaki, Jackson), Defendant/Appellant Fleming appealed from a trial court order denying its […]