FAA Collective Actions And Related State Law Class Actions Governed By Individualized Arbitration Proceedings Under Employment Contract. On May 21, 2018, the United State Supreme Court issued its decision in Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, 584 U.S. __, No. 16-285. SCOTUS decided that the FAA instructed federal courts to enforce individualized arbitration proceedings under an […]
Issue Deals With Whether Generalized Language Was Akin To Silence Under Stolt-Nielsen. In Stolt-Nielsen v. AnimalFeeds International Corp., 55 U.S. 662, 684, 687 (2010), the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) held that the differences between bilateral and class-action arbitration are too great to presume the parties’ mere silence on the issue of class-action arbitration constitutes […]
Gentry v. Superior Court: It's Alive, It's Alive! Gentry v. Superior Court (2007) 42 Cal.4th 443 (Gentry) held that class action waiver provisions in a contract are unenforceable, and a motion to compel arbitration may be denied, where the so-called "Gentry factors" are satisfied, and it is determined that a class action is a […]
Epic Systems Corp. And Consolidated Cases Pit FAA Against NLRA. Does the right to arbitrate a case under the Federal Arbitration Act trump the right of employees to engage in concerted activity under the National Labor Relations Act by filing a class action lawsuit against an employer? Oral argument in Epic […]
A Couple Of New Tidbits From SCOTUS Blog. Amy Howe posted again in SCOTUSBlog on September 25, 2017, about the upcoming hearing on October 2 of Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, Ernst & Young LLP v. Morris, and National Labor Relations Board v. Murphy Oil USA, cases requiring SCOTUS to reconcile the Federal […]
Headline Of Article In The Economist Neatly Sums Up The Stakes: "Can Companies Block Employees' Class-Action Lawsuits?" Steven Mazie has authored an article in the September 20, 2017 online edition of The Economist about the competing interests at stake in the three arbitration cases that SCOTUS will hear on October 2 at the […]
Arbitration Was Required Under A Collective Bargaining Agreement That Did Not Provide For Class Arbitration. Brushing aside thorny appealability issues, Cortez v. Doty Bros. Equipment Company, B275255 (2/7 filed 8/15, pub. order 9/1/17) (Perluss, Zelon, Segal) treated an employee's appeal as a writ of mandate, enabling the Court to address the effect of […]
Unreasonable Delay Supported Trial Court's Finding Of Prejudice, Resulting In Waiver Of Right To Arbitrate. Sprunk, et al. v. Prisma LLC, B268755 (2/1 8/23/17) (Lui, Chaney, Johnson) holds that, under the circumstances, defendant Prisma LLC aka "Plan B", an employer of exotic dancers, waived its right to seek arbitration "by filing and then […]
Subscript Law Has A Snappy Explainer. Today's SCOTUSBlog mentions that Subscript Law has a nice explainer boiling down three consolidated arbitration cases that the United States Supreme Court will be hearing at the beginning of its new term. The key issue in these cases: can employees sign away their rights to file class […]
My Mini-Comment Is Posted To NYT Website. Anita Hill, who famously testified during Justice Clarence Thomas's confirmation hearing, has written an Op-Ed for the NYT entitled, "Class Actions Could Fight Discrimination In Tech", appearing on-line today, August 8, 2017. She observes, uncontroversially: "Women in tech no doubt have hurdles to bringing class-action lawsuits, including […]